How I cut down on coffee without giving it up

I am not giving up coffee. I am just not drinking it at four in the afternoon any more, and that turned out to be most of the problem.

Every article about sleep tells you to cut out caffeine. Very few tell you how to do it without three days of headaches and a personality change.

What worked, in order

  • Keep the morning coffee. The one you actually enjoy. Do not touch it, or you will resent the whole experiment.
  • Move the cut-off to 1pm. Not 5pm. One o'clock, for two weeks, and see what happens to your sleep.
  • Half-decaf your afternoon cup. Mix half regular grounds with half decaf. Most people cannot taste the difference after a week.
  • Swap the third cup for something with a ritual. The habit is often the point, not the caffeine. A proper tea, or a decaf in the good mug.
  • Drink water before you decide you need coffee. Half the time, that is the whole problem.

What happened

My 3am wake-ups went from five a week to two, and the ones that remained were the nights I had wine. I also stopped getting the 11am shaky feeling, which I had assumed was low blood sugar and was probably caffeine on an empty stomach.

What did not happen: I did not become a morning person, and I still need the first coffee. Some things are not negotiable.

If you are adding supplements

Check the label for caffeine. Metabolism and energy products often contain it, sometimes 100mg or more, and stacking that on top of coffee is a common cause of palpitations and 4am waking. If you are sensitive, an evening-friendly product makes more sense than one that keeps you up.