Hormone therapy: the basics, without the scare stories
I am not a doctor and this is not medical advice. But the conversation about hormone therapy has been so distorted that it is worth knowing what the actual position is.
For twenty years, a generation of women were told hormone therapy caused breast cancer and should be avoided. That message came from one large study, reported in a way that flattened the detail, and it is only recently that the detail has been properly explained.
What it is
Hormone therapy replaces the hormones your body is producing less of. There are two main types:
- Oestrogen only, for women who have had a hysterectomy.
- Combined oestrogen and progestogen, for women with a uterus, because oestrogen alone thickens the womb lining and raises the risk of womb cancer. The progestogen protects against that.
Both come as tablets, patches, gels and sprays. Transdermal versions (patches and gels) are often preferred because they carry a lower clot risk than tablets.
What it helps
Hormone therapy is the most effective treatment for hot flushes and night sweats, and it typically improves sleep, mood, joint aches and genitourinary symptoms too. Local oestrogen, as a cream or pessary, treats vaginal dryness and urinary symptoms specifically and can be used on its own.
What the risks actually are
These numbers are worth knowing because they are much smaller than the headlines suggested:
- Combined therapy is associated with a small increase in breast cancer risk, roughly equivalent to the increase from a couple of glasses of wine a night, and the risk falls after stopping.
- Oestrogen-only therapy does not appear to increase breast cancer risk in the same way.
- Oral oestrogen slightly increases clot risk; transdermal does not to the same degree.
- Starting therapy after 60, or more than ten years after menopause, carries different considerations than starting in your early fifties.
All of this depends on your personal history. A family history of breast cancer or a previous clot changes the conversation, and that is a conversation for a clinician who knows your details.
Questions worth asking
- Am I a candidate for hormone therapy, given my history?
- Would transdermal be better for me than tablets?
- What dose would you start me on, and when would we review it?
- Do I need a progestogen, and which type?
- What should I do if I get side effects?
- How long can I stay on it, and how do we decide when to stop?
The bottom line
It is a treatment with real benefits and real risks, and the balance differs from person to person. What it is not is a dangerous option to be avoided at all costs, which is what a lot of us were told. If you are struggling, it is worth asking the question properly rather than assuming the answer is no.