Which supplements are actually worth taking in perimenopause

Some have decent evidence behind them. Some have none. Very little of it is essential.

I am not a doctor and this is not medical advice. But I can tell you what the evidence looks like from the outside, and what I do myself, and where the marketing gets ahead of the science.

Reasonable to consider

  • Vitamin D in winter, or year round if you cover up or rarely go outside. 10 micrograms a day is the usual public health advice in the UK.
  • Calcium from food first, and a supplement only if your diet is short. Bone loss accelerates around menopause.
  • Omega 3 if you do not eat oily fish twice a week. Modest evidence for joints and mood, cheap enough to be worth it.
  • Magnesium for sleep and cramps. The evidence is mixed, but it is cheap and low risk for most people. It gives some women loose stools, so start low.
  • Iron only if a blood test shows you need it. Do not take it blind, because too much iron is harmful.

Where the evidence is thin

Most "menopause support" blends, hormone-balancing teas, and proprietary plant extracts have small studies behind them, often funded by the manufacturer. That does not mean they are useless, but it means nobody can tell you they work for you.

Black cohosh and red clover are the two most studied botanical options for flushes. Results are mixed, and black cohosh has rare liver concerns, so it is worth mentioning to a doctor before you start.

How to read a label

  • Look at the amounts, not the ingredient list. A blend that lists twelve ingredients often has a token sprinkle of each.
  • Check for a third-party testing mark. Supplements are not regulated like medicines, so independent testing is your only assurance of what is in the bottle.
  • Ignore "clinically proven" unless it says which study. It usually means one small study on something adjacent.
  • Watch for hidden caffeine in metabolism products. It is a common cause of palpitations and 4am waking.

What I actually take

Vitamin D in winter, magnesium most evenings, and one joint supplement that I have repurchased more than once. I have written about it honestly, including the parts that are marketing rather than science.

JointVive Ad · affiliate link

A daily liquid drop for aching joints.

What it is

One drop a day, straight or in a drink. Nine plant ingredients: pine bark extract, tamarind, chlorella, ginkgo biloba, spirulina, lion's mane, bacopa, moringa and neem.

What it is for

Designed to support joint comfort, flexibility and mobility.

Why I recommend it

The ingredients are named and the label is published, and the refund period is a full year — the longest I have seen in this category. That gives you time to judge whether it helps with stairs, gardening or getting up off the floor.

Who it suits

Women whose joints are limiting ordinary things: stairs, walks, playing with children.

What to know first

A blend of nine ingredients is not the same as a clinical trial of the blend. If a joint is swollen, hot, red or suddenly worse, see a doctor rather than buying a supplement.

Price

When I last checked: $69 for one bottle, $59 per bottle for three, $29 per bottle for six.

View JointVive

365-day money-back guarantee. Opens the manufacturer's site in a new tab. I earn a commission if you buy, and the price is the same for you. Statements have not been evaluated by the FDA; not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent disease; results vary.

More about JointVive →

Everything else I have tried has either done nothing or done something I could not distinguish from a good week. That is not a satisfying answer, but it is an honest one.